| Player | Club | |
|---|---|---|
| 2019 | Isabella Rea | South Warrnambool |
| 2018 | Chelsea Baker | Camperdown |
| 2017 | Emily Pertzel | Hamilton Kangaroos |
| 2017 | Libby Moloney | Terang Mortlake |
| 2016 | Libby Moloney | Terang Mortlake |
| 2015 | Emily Kermeen | Hamilton Kangaroos |
| 2014 | Ally O'Connor | South Warrnambool |
| 2013 | Genevieve O'Connor | South Warrnambool |
| 2012 | Sarah Moroney | Port Fairy |
| 2011 | Sarah Moroney | Port Fairy |
| 2010 | Rebekah Moroney | Port Fairy |
| 2009 | Annie Forrest | Port Fairy |
| 2008 | Laura Blackburn | North Warrnambool Eagles |
| 2007 | Emily-Rose Finnigan | Warrnambool |
| 2006 | Jessie Meade | Terang Mortlake |
| 2005 | Hannah McElgunn | Koroit |
| 2004 | Lisa Morey | Camperdown |
| 2003 | Laura Noonan | Koroit |
| 2001 | Kate Wilson | Camperdown |
| 2000 | Emily Batt | Warrnambool |
| 1999 | Haylee Finn | South Warrnambool |
| 1998 | Haylee Finn | South Warrnambool |
| 1996 | Bronwyn Morris | Cobden |
| 1995 | Danielle McIlroy | Port Fairy |
| 1994 | Kate O'Sullivan | Terang |
| 1993 | Rebecca Ryan | Colac |
| 1992 | Sarah Titmus | Camperdown |